TY - JOUR
T1 - Trace-element zoning patterns in porphyroblastic garnets in low-t eclogites
T2 - Parameter optimization of the diffusion-limited ree-uptake model
AU - Fukushima, Ryo
AU - Tsujimori, Tatsuki
AU - Aoki, Shogo
AU - Aoki, Kazumasa
N1 - Funding Information:
This research was supported by CNEAS at Tohoku University in part by grants from the MEXT/JSPS KAKENHI JP15H05212 and JP18H01299 to Tatsuki Tsujimori. This was also supported by MEXT Private University Research Branding Project (Okayama University of Science) to Kazumasa Aoki and JSPS KAKENHI JP19K04043 to Kazumasa Aoki. Tatsuki Tsujimori and Ryo Fukushima acknowledge the International Joint Graduate Program in Earth and Environmental Sciences (GP-EES) and the JSPS Japanese–German Graduate Externship. The authors thank Daniel Pastor-Galán for his feedback. We are deeply grateful to Tadao Nishiyama and the anonymous reviewer for the highly stimulating discussion, and Yuji Ichiyama for his editorial handling of this manuscript.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.
PY - 2021/1/1
Y1 - 2021/1/1
N2 - Compositional zoning patterns of the major elements and REEs in prograde-zoned garnets whose Mg/(Mg + Fe) atomic ratios increase rimward have been widely used to understand the metamorphic P–T–t trajectories, and the diffusion-limited REE-uptake model is a promising way to interpret their growth rates and the REE diffusion kinetics in the low-temperature eclogite. In order to elucidate their growth kinetics with Skora et al.'s (2006) diffusion-limited REE uptake model for prograde-zoned garnets, we examine the trace-element zoning patterns of two prograde-zoned porphyroblastic garnets (~6 mm in size) in low-temperature eclogites from two different localities. Core-to-rim trace-element profiles in a garnet (prp5–9-alm61–67 sps1–3 grs24–30 ) of a glaucophane-bearing epidote eclogite of Syros (Cyclades, Greece) are characterized by the presence of Y + HREE peaks in the mantle, which might be attributed to a continuous breakdown of the titanite to form rutile during the garnet growth. In contrast, those in a garnet (prp4–7 alm61–68-sps3–10 grs23–24 ) extracted from a lawsonite-eclogite of the South Motagua Mélange (SMM) (Guatemala) have prominent central peaks of Y + HREEs. Although the REE profiles of both the garnets can be explained by the diffusion-limited uptake, their Mn profiles suggest that their growth-rate laws are different: i.e., diffusion-con-trolled (Syros) and interface-controlled (SMM). Prior to the model application, we optimize the number of the parameters as the garnet grows with the interface-controlled processes based on the growth Péclet number. In particular, we propose the ratio of the REE diffusivity in the eclogitic matrix to the garnet growth rate as the new parameter. Visualizing the values of the new parameters allows to readily understand the relationship between the REE profiles and the REE-diffusion/gar-net-growth kinetics in low-T eclogite. Our model refinement leads to the simple quantitative characterization of core-to-rim REE profiles in garnet in low-temperature eclogites.
AB - Compositional zoning patterns of the major elements and REEs in prograde-zoned garnets whose Mg/(Mg + Fe) atomic ratios increase rimward have been widely used to understand the metamorphic P–T–t trajectories, and the diffusion-limited REE-uptake model is a promising way to interpret their growth rates and the REE diffusion kinetics in the low-temperature eclogite. In order to elucidate their growth kinetics with Skora et al.'s (2006) diffusion-limited REE uptake model for prograde-zoned garnets, we examine the trace-element zoning patterns of two prograde-zoned porphyroblastic garnets (~6 mm in size) in low-temperature eclogites from two different localities. Core-to-rim trace-element profiles in a garnet (prp5–9-alm61–67 sps1–3 grs24–30 ) of a glaucophane-bearing epidote eclogite of Syros (Cyclades, Greece) are characterized by the presence of Y + HREE peaks in the mantle, which might be attributed to a continuous breakdown of the titanite to form rutile during the garnet growth. In contrast, those in a garnet (prp4–7 alm61–68-sps3–10 grs23–24 ) extracted from a lawsonite-eclogite of the South Motagua Mélange (SMM) (Guatemala) have prominent central peaks of Y + HREEs. Although the REE profiles of both the garnets can be explained by the diffusion-limited uptake, their Mn profiles suggest that their growth-rate laws are different: i.e., diffusion-con-trolled (Syros) and interface-controlled (SMM). Prior to the model application, we optimize the number of the parameters as the garnet grows with the interface-controlled processes based on the growth Péclet number. In particular, we propose the ratio of the REE diffusivity in the eclogitic matrix to the garnet growth rate as the new parameter. Visualizing the values of the new parameters allows to readily understand the relationship between the REE profiles and the REE-diffusion/gar-net-growth kinetics in low-T eclogite. Our model refinement leads to the simple quantitative characterization of core-to-rim REE profiles in garnet in low-temperature eclogites.
KW - Diffusion-limited REE uptake model
KW - Eclogite
KW - Growth kinetics
KW - Zoned garnet
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85102556720&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85102556720&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1111/iar.12394
DO - 10.1111/iar.12394
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85102556720
SN - 1038-4871
VL - 30
SP - 1
EP - 17
JO - Island Arc
JF - Island Arc
IS - 1
M1 - e12394
ER -