TY - JOUR
T1 - Trace element partitioning between majoritic garnet and silicate melt at 10-17GPa
T2 - Implications for deep mantle processes
AU - Corgne, Alexandre
AU - Armstrong, Lora S.
AU - Keshav, Shantanu
AU - Fei, Yingwei
AU - McDonough, William F.
AU - Minarik, William G.
AU - Moreno, Karen
N1 - Funding Information:
The Carnegie Institution of Washington (postdoctoral fellowships to AC and SK and internship to LSA), the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (Cosmochemistry grant NNG04GG09G to YF, the Geotop research centre (grant to WGM)) and the National Science Foundation (grants EAR0337621 and EAR0739006 to WFM) supported this research. AC and SK also benefited from the financial support from the INSU-CNRS ‘Programme National de Planétologie’ and the Bayerisches Geoinstitut , respectively. We are grateful to Richard Ash for his help during LA–ICP-MS analyses, Chris Hadidiacos for his help with experiments and EPMA analyses, Erik Hauri for SIMS analysis of prospective runs, Carol Lawson for XRF analysis of the starting composition, and Thomas Stachel and Ralf Tappert for providing data on majoritic garnet inclusions in diamonds. We are also grateful to Kenneth Collerson and Thomas Stachel for their formal reviews and Andrew Kerr for editorial handling.
PY - 2012/9/1
Y1 - 2012/9/1
N2 - Melting experiments were performed on a silica-rich peridotite composition at 10-17GPa to determine majoritic garnet-melt partition coefficients (D) for major and trace elements. Our results show that D for many elements, including Na, Sc, Y and rare earth elements (REE), varies significantly with increasing pressure or proportion of majorite component. Lu and Sc become incompatible at 17GPa, with D decreasing from 1.5 at 10GPa to 0.9 at 17GPa. As predicted from lattice strain, log D for isovalent cations entering the large site of majoritic garnet exhibits a near-parabolic dependence on ionic radius. Our data are used to refine a previously published predictive model for garnet-melt partitioning of trivalent cations, which suffered from a lack of calibration in the 10-20GPa range. Our results suggest that Archean Al-depleted komatiites from Barberton (South Africa) may have been generated by partial melting of dry peridotite at depths between 200 and 400km. We also speculate that transition zone diamonds from Kankan (Guinea), which contain inclusions of majoritic garnet, may have formed from the partial reduction of CO 2-rich magmas that subsequently transported them to the surface. This hypothesis would provide an explanation for the REE patterns of majoritic garnet trapped within these diamonds, including Eu anomalies. Finally, we show that segregation of majoritic garnet-bearing cumulates during crystallisation of a deep Martian magma ocean could lead to a variety of Lu/Hf and Sm/Nd ratios depending on pressure, leading to a range of ε 143Nd and ε 176Hf isotope signatures for potential mantle sources of Martian rocks.
AB - Melting experiments were performed on a silica-rich peridotite composition at 10-17GPa to determine majoritic garnet-melt partition coefficients (D) for major and trace elements. Our results show that D for many elements, including Na, Sc, Y and rare earth elements (REE), varies significantly with increasing pressure or proportion of majorite component. Lu and Sc become incompatible at 17GPa, with D decreasing from 1.5 at 10GPa to 0.9 at 17GPa. As predicted from lattice strain, log D for isovalent cations entering the large site of majoritic garnet exhibits a near-parabolic dependence on ionic radius. Our data are used to refine a previously published predictive model for garnet-melt partitioning of trivalent cations, which suffered from a lack of calibration in the 10-20GPa range. Our results suggest that Archean Al-depleted komatiites from Barberton (South Africa) may have been generated by partial melting of dry peridotite at depths between 200 and 400km. We also speculate that transition zone diamonds from Kankan (Guinea), which contain inclusions of majoritic garnet, may have formed from the partial reduction of CO 2-rich magmas that subsequently transported them to the surface. This hypothesis would provide an explanation for the REE patterns of majoritic garnet trapped within these diamonds, including Eu anomalies. Finally, we show that segregation of majoritic garnet-bearing cumulates during crystallisation of a deep Martian magma ocean could lead to a variety of Lu/Hf and Sm/Nd ratios depending on pressure, leading to a range of ε 143Nd and ε 176Hf isotope signatures for potential mantle sources of Martian rocks.
KW - Diamonds
KW - Garnet
KW - Komatiites
KW - Majorite
KW - Mars
KW - Trace elements
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84863215745&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84863215745&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.lithos.2012.06.013
DO - 10.1016/j.lithos.2012.06.013
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84863215745
SN - 0024-4937
VL - 148
SP - 128
EP - 141
JO - Lithos
JF - Lithos
ER -